Brief #12

-
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/brief-12-jim-caruso-qrbvc/
-
November 19, 2026

By Jim Caruso

‍

In The News

Ogilvy and CAA launch partnership to clone celebrity talent for AI ads

‍
Would you trust an ad if you knew the star in it never actually showed up for the shoot?

‍

Ogilvy and CAA are betting you will. They’ve launched something called Echo, and once it’s up and running, Ogilvy says it will be able to make AI ads with the actors, athletes, and creators CAA represents all by using their digital likeness. The first pilots are supposed to go live by the end of the year.

‍

Having worked in creative and production agencies, I see two really interesting parts of this story that could change a lot for the ad industry, and for the ongoing conversation about consumer trust in the age of generative AI.

‍

In terms of mechanics, it’s fascinating that CAA didn’t need to build anything new for this. As Digiday reported, the agency has had the Vault for about four years: a studio with 204 cameras that scans a person from head to toe, down to how they walk, and even picks up subtle nuances. Until now, that mostly went toward movies.

‍
This level of realism is being talked about widely with the launch of GTA6, similarly being hailed as a seminal moment in just how realistic you can make digital images behave and even look like humans.

‍

On the talent side, per Digiday, they can keep ownership of their likeness, have a say in final approval, and turn down brands or markets they don’t want to associate with.  Further downstream, each ad gets a watermark saying it’s AI and that the star approved it. The rub will still be how consumers connect with these ads and respond to them.

‍

Ogilvy’s estimate is that cost per asset drops by 65-75%.

‍

That’s an appealing and shockingly high number that would, of course, be music to brand executives’ ears. Creatives, agencies, and production houses, probably less so.
I’d bet it catches on quickly anyway; the savings are hard to argue with if they prove true, not to mention the efficiency and faster time to market. Some fundamentals, however, wouldn’t change; I’d still want to see whose audience aligns with my customers before signing anyone. It’s still about breaking down your target audience by behavior, purchase history, and engagement, and figuring out which voices actually reach the people a brand cares about.

‍

The science of data meets the art of fandom, as we like to say. Clone or no clone, that part doesn’t change. There’s ultimately always the bottom line as it relates to the impact these have; whatever percentage savings you create won’t matter much if these ads don’t deliver an impact.

‍

Inside EPIC

‍

After reading about Echo, and what could become a much more limitless, flexible way to tap into talent that's most relevant for consumers, I wanted to see which voices basketball fans actually pay attention to as an example. So I went into EPIC’s consumer insights platform and compared NBA and WNBA fans with the general US 18+ population, looking at who and what they follow on social media - thinking about how a brand would approach this if they wanted to advertise to these fans; what would make sense?

‍

Some of the biggest names land near the national average. Some of the most-followed basketball names in this group, from LeBron James to Shaquille O’Neal, are only 2% to 9% more likely to be followed by these fans than by US adults overall, so fans don’t really show much difference when it comes to the stars.

‍

Anthony Edwards, who stars in many Sprite commercials, was paired with Kevin Garnett last year in a spot called “Lock In.” It’s basically the two of them in a car talking about life in the league, with Sprite barely on screen. With these fans, Edwards is only 4% more likely to be followed than with US adults overall. Garnett is 21% more likely.

‍

What does change is who they follow beyond the stars. When you look at the widely followed basketball names fans over-index on, the icons are present. Steve Kerr is 26% higher, Phil Jackson 20%, and Jeanie Buss 18%, so coaches and front-office people do well. Same goes for older legends like Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Chris Webber (18% each). Out of the top 20, only a couple are active players, including Caitlin Clark and Joel Embiid. The stars are followed just as widely by everyone else. If a brand actually wants to connect with these fans, it’s worth looking at the people around them, too.

‍

The people who cover the game do a lot better. Our NBA/WNBA fan audiences are roughly 20% to 30% more likely to follow basketball personalities, including Michael Wilbon, Shams Charania, and Marc Stein. Chad Ford (35%), Doug Gottlieb (33%), Rex Chapman (31%), and Doris Burke (30%) actually top the list of widely followed basketball names. The Bill Simmons Podcast does well with them too: fans are 28% more likely to follow it on social.

‍

On the WNBA side, some of the players beat the league. It’s often said that basketball, more than some other sports, is a ‘players league’. With the WNBA, we saw Sue Bird (30%) and Caitlin Clark (26%) over-index well above the league’s own account (8%), although the WNBA’s most-followed players, Skylar Diggins and Angel Reese, land right at average. Unsurprisingly, Clark is all over commercials, from State Farm to Xfinity, and both brands over-index with these fans too. They’re 8% more likely than US adults to follow State Farm and 24% more likely to follow Xfinity.

‍

Beyond Clark, few WNBA names have become ad staples right now. But based on what’s happening with this audience, Rebecca Lobo (40%), Renee Montgomery (28%) and Tamika Catchings (20%) may be good options. Their followings are smaller than Clark’s, so they’d be a play for a closer connection rather than reach.

‍

The brands already testing clones show up here too. Snickers and Coca-Cola, two brands that have run ads with José Mourinho’s digital clone, both over-index with these fans.

‍

However, general celebrity sites on their own don’t do much for these fans. Celebrity and gossip websites are about 11% less likely to be followed by these fans than by US adults overall.

‍

So what does that mean for brands? While some of the biggest stars still reach more of these fans than any broadcaster or reporter, the voices that over-index are the ones talking about the game every day, and a famous face alone probably isn’t what gets their attention.

‍

Consumer Corner: What Im Into This Week;

‍

Listening: The Bill Simmons Podcast

‍

Bill Simmons has been doing this longer than almost anyone, and it still holds up. Thanksgiving football is a week away, so I’m catching up on the NFL.

‍

Watching: Manchester United at Liverpool

‍

Manchester United are back from the international break with a new manager, Mauricio Pochettino. He officially takes over this week after finishing up with the US men’s team, and his first game is Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday. Kickoff is 11:30 a.m. ET. Biased, since Elevate is United’s Official Hospitality Partner, but his first game should be a good one.

‍

Drinking: Silver Oak Cabernet

Still in Thanksgiving mode after last week’s torta di mele. My pick for the table this year is a Silver Oak Cab. It holds up to everything on the plate, and it’s an easy bottle to bring if you’re not the one hosting. It’s also great to sip on while recipe testing.